They also found one of Marie’s kitchen knives next to the bed and her learner’s permit—oddly removed from her wallet—on the bedroom windowsill. The Marshall Project (Ken Armstrong) and ProPublica (T. Christian Miller), 16 December 2015."An 18-year-old said she was attacked at knifepoint. In this particular case, like I mentioned earlier, we needed the listeners to understand the details of the event to a certain extent, to be able to understand Marie. Robyn Semien: Trying to move on or something. accompanied by Detective Rittgarn, went to pick up Marie at . When youâre writing for the ear, how do you weigh whether you should narrate a stream of events or whether you should turn it over to your character to recount something? Yeah. Southern Horrors provides a startling view into the Jim Crow South where the precarious and subordinate position of women linked black and white anti-rape activists together in fragile political alliances. And that just– well, in the 25 years in law enforcement, my experience has been people that ask that are usually in trouble. Two days later, Marie was questioned further by the detectives and persuaded to write not one, but two counter statements. Kayla Blanton is a freelance writer who reports on all things health and nutrition for Men’s Health, Women’s Health, and Prevention. Between Feb. 9 and Feb. 25, the same masked man has robbed gas stations, convenience stores and a smoke shop in Lynnwood and other parts of South Snohomish County, according to police Detective Jerry Rittgarn. Were you wondering, why is she being made to say this? Itâs a little idiosyncratic. The Lynnwood Police Department had 79 sworn officers, serving a city of about 34,000 people. It’s a tactic police use when they’re interrogating someone they suspect in a crime. The real-life counterpart of Bill Fagerbakke's hard-hearted Detective Pruitt, Jerry Rittgarn threatened Adler with . EDITORâS NOTE: Read our conversation with Robyn Semien of This American Life and Ken Armstrong, formerly of The Marshall Project, on how those two organizations and ProPublica partnered to tell this story across multiple platforms. In this ground-breaking practical reference, the family of aspartic acid proteases is described from a drug developer's perspective. So I immediately went in and called the Kirkland Police Department and asked to speak to the lead detective on the rape case. Marie spent time with two former foster moms in the days following her rape—Peggy Cunningham and Shannon McQuery. Robyn Semien: He said if she went to the police, he’d put the pictures he had of her online. This one is tricky. And I kind of–. They both developed doubts about the assault. No, I told her that I had doubts about whether or not she was telling the truth. This framing right from the get-go â seeds of doubt germinating with those close to Marie, as opposed to the more typical narrative of the police or institutions sowing that doubt â feels important to the framing of the rest of the piece. And it was a very different conversation from the first time police talked to Marie. We double checked with Elisabeth before airing it. She’s telling everybody about it. Detectives do not know why she made the story up. Sometimes an injustice comes along and you think 'No, this cannot be', and rather than just turn off the TV, you know it's time to act' So begins Isabel Losada's extraordinary FOR TIBET WITH LOVE in which she explores whether it's possible ... It was the tone of her voice. This question came from one of our astute editors, Brian Reed. Her record was cleared and her fees returned. It really did keep coming up. My colleague, Lilly Sullivan, did the legwork to find this, and itâs a tidbit I have thought about all the time since. The freshly dead body sprawled on the Bedford Square doorstep of General Brandon Balantyne is an affront to every respectable sensibility. “The terrible reality of it is that, you know, it was — for me it was just an opportunity, which is disgusting, and I know that,” he says, “but that’s — you know, that’s the truth.”. After hours of questioning Marie, Detective Parker calls in some backup. In TAL radio stories, is it common for you to jump in and out so frequently between a source and a producer? I wanted to be able to try to talk about it and get it out. The tests are seen as a deterrent to women coming forward to report sexual assault. And I just got this really weird feeling. One of the girls, she was calling me and making threats at me, thought I was a liar and basically mentally ill for making up something like that. And she had a support system that could have helped her find one. It was proven later beyond a shadow of a doubt. Â And then that mistake spreads to officials and friends and acquaintances until it is impossible for them all to see the truth, even when new proof comes to light, even when it’s all right there in front of them. She’d go on supervised probation, pay $500 in court costs, and she’d get mental health counseling, not for being raped but for lying about it. Isnât it? This doesn’t seem like what you would do. It seemed right, in that sense, to start with something of an origin story of doubt, and I believe we all felt Shannonâs story was the most compelling. Further evidence that could have been gathered never was. Why did you include the details of how the rape occurred? She was there at the meeting, along with nine or so others, mostly girls, and the program managers, sitting in chairs in a circle. Itâs a real lesson in the story about the importance of objectivity in investigations. Jeffrey Mason and Jerry Rittgarn, pressed on the inconsistencies in her story. And the only way they would leave me alone is if I wrote a statement saying that it didn’t happen. How many years after the rape did you report this part out, and did Peggy struggle to remember any details of that day? There is no such statistic kept. Jerry Rittgarn asked Marie, according to the report. The book-length version fills in his portrait, and it is chilling. In sum, Marie did not act the way a rape victim, in their estimation, should. “I was, for lack of a better word, enslaved to something I’ve detested my entire life,” he after his arrest in 2011. Sergeant Rinta’s review went on, quote, “If this hadn’t been documented in their reports, I would have been skeptical that this actually happened.” The victim’s credibility, quote, “became the focus of the investigation, and all of the strong evidence that pointed to a serious felony crime was completely ignored.” Here’s Marie. The first part of the story takes place mostly in Lynnwood, Washington, near Seattle. Ken Armstrong: Marie gets along with people. You’ll love our magazine! The character of Detective Pruitt (played by Bill Fagerbakke) is loosely based on Jerry Rittgarn, who was the one who first blatantly told Marie he didn't believe her story. Rittgarn had been with the department for 11 years, the last four as a detective. It kept changing. I wanted listeners to really understand some type of way â via research â to think about Marie and the trauma she had experienced. Jeffrey Mason and Jerry Rittgarn, arrived at the scene, investigated, and took statements..All was above board until later, when Judith called the police to tell them she . It feels sort of human, albeit wrong, to place any inch of responsibility at Marieâs feet â because of something she did or didnât say, or a way she did or didnât act before or after being attacked. Sherwood Forest is in danger of being destroyed and it's up to Robin and his band of dimwitted Merry Men to save the day. That's where our story begins." "'An Unbelievable Story of Rape' is the account of a failed police investigation and the trail of hurt and . And possibly maybe I had dreamt that stuff that first day, maybe I had dreamt it up and that it maybe didn’t happen and stuff like that. People treated her like she was– they couldn’t get far enough away from her. The description of his background comes from his LinkedIn profile. And so I was like, OK, never mind. I hope you start to see the fix Marie is really in with this exchange. In TAL radio stories, is it common for you to jump in and out so frequently between a source and a producer? In any case, both detectives wrote in their reports that Marie seemed unsure of her story. It felt like, just, what’s this drama going on? Rape Victim Gets $150,000 After Police Accuse Her Of Lying. She moved around a lot when she was a kid in the foster care system– she thinks 10 or 11 different families, not including group homes. I thought there should have been more investigation, that it was just too similar. No one has been injured in the robberies. Based on those doubts, the detectives coerced her into recanting and then charged her with a crime: false reporting. He took pictures,â etc. They informed her that multiple other women were assaulted in the same exact fashion, and evidence was found to prove her innocence. They gave up carbs together for a few weeks. She’s calling everybody that she knows and telling them. Marie: He told me that if I took a lie detector test and it came back that I was lying, that he was going to take me to jail himself. Between 2008 and 2011, a series of rapes in the suburbs around Seattle and Denver were perpetrated by Marc Patrick O'Leary, an Army veteran who had previously been stationed near Tacoma, Washington. And I got this– I’m a big Law and Order fan. When youâre scripting, what makes you decide to include questions from a reporterâs original interview? That was the only time I saw her get mad the whole day. Marie was blindfolded, and her attacker wore a mask, so there wasn’t a real description. And she’d say, “you know, I’m not really a liar. The second investigation, where the police do a stunningly great job, in a minute, when our program continues. And they just started asking me all these questions and just grilling at me. In the first, she wrote that the rape had been a dream . Robyn Semien: Shannon remembers that phone call with Peggy, too. Slip on These Walking Shoes for All-Day Comfort. Elisabeth says Marie was avoided like– Â. Elisabeth: The plague. I was crying, and I was upset. In my mind, I was second-guessing somebody coming into my house and doing all this stuff, you know? Ira Glass: Peggy remembers hearing about the shoelaces and adding them to her list of things that just didn’t make sense. Why did you include the details of how the rape occurred? The very thought terrified her. We definitely did with Shannon. “But this bitch is the reason that nobody believes when women say they get raped.”. He knew her name. And I just– all of a sudden, I was just like, am I in trouble? And people, they were very cruel to her. It feels like such an important question, and really the crux of the whole story â this question could have been directed at any of the other people in Marieâs life who didnât believe her. But they were in the minority. One of them is done so inspiringly well, it’s like the detectives in it are like detectives on a television show– smart and resourceful and great judgment and just police at their very best. Shannon: Well, Peggy also didn’t believe her. I mean, I even remember reading one of the comments on the– it was on the internet, but I don’t remember what exactly page it was or anything. Prevention participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. For Marie, it was too much. Elisabeth: Marie stood up. Robyn Semien: Then, that same day, Marie called several of her friends, not just her closest ones, to tell them about the rape. So, what really happened during Marie’s case? Thank you. Why did you include two descriptions of the same exchange back-to-back? The dots were connecting themselves, and amidst their search for more, they uncovered another victim who had escaped a similar attack around the same time. $28. A firm understanding of those basic concepts will enable your child to master more difficult games and activities to improve your child's math skills while having fun. Detective Jerry Rittgarn challenged Marie directly, telling her that "her story and the evidence didn't match" and that he believed she had made the story up. She trusted their judgment. This is Peggy. His work is consistently different in style, politically challenging, and ranges across essays, plays, poems, stories and novels, two of which have been filmed. This book is the first full-length study of his work. . And I won’t have to deal with them right now. Depends. Plus, they’re famously unreliable, especially on someone who’s traumatized. You can also visit online.rainn.org to receive support via confidential online chat. When a mysterious young woman is found on the tropical island of Fala'isi, Luke Chapman insists that she remain at his home. Marie: Like, I had to hide. Friend-wise, that was about it. Ira Glass: Shannon felt awful doubting Marie. We reached out to the Project Ladder managers, but they never replied. And she said that she had lied about what had happened. Marie: I told him that I wanted to recant and that it really did happen. Why did you include two descriptions of the same exchange back-to-back? One detective said she figured the Lynnwood police knew their case best. The journalists from different organizations who came upon the story recognized those challenges, but also the layers and layers of potential it offered: Telling what happened to one young woman could peel back flaws in the system that fails so many. What purpose did that structure serve for this part of the story in particular? Played by Kaitlyn Dever in Unbelievable, Marie was forced to move on with her life, carrying the trauma of her attack and the associated lies, until two years later, when she was randomly approached by police. Others were less willing to engage publicly in such self-reflection. The false reporting charge meant that Marie’s rape case would be officially closed. Five years later, she's getting justice. The in-depth piece considers every disturbing detail, most of which were studied and implemented (many times word for word) into the story’s TV rendition. This content is imported from YouTube. Marie: So then they said, OK. Well, we’re going to go to the police station. Yes, this framing guided all of our reporting. The Marshall Project (Ken Armstrong) and ProPublica (T. Christian Miller), 16 December 2015."An 18-year-old said she was attacked at knifepoint. Storyboardâs questions are in red; Semien’s responses in blue. Robyn Semien: What does it look like when you kind of decide to flip the switch and stop caring so much? I love how in the first instance that we hear from Marie, sheâs talking about what freedom feels like to her. Marie remembers it as the lowest moment of this whole ordeal, the one time she thought about suicide. And, you know, I don’t know if that guy ever got away or ended up hurting other people because I never told anybody, never talked to anybody about it. An unexpected strength of the book is the chance it affords Jeffrey Mason, one of the original detectives who doubted Marie, to look back on his mistakes. Ken Armstrong: Sergeant Mason didn’t have a lot of experience investigating sexual assault. Dia berkata bahwa dia dibangunkan oleh seorang pria yang menyumpal, menutup mata, dan memperkosanya di apartemen. Through diagrams, sketches and models the author defines and delineates the precise step-by-step procedures of scenographic modelmaking. Jerry Rittmann Branch Manager at Heritage Crystal Clean Marion, AR. Pruitt and Eric Lange played Det. Then she said she made it up. Ken Armstrong: Do you think you were starting to look for things that didn’t ring true? As The Marshall Project article specifies, Manson (who was the lead investigator), had previously only worked on patrol and in . Marie’s case forced him, for the first time, to question his fitness for the job. THE STORY: A darkly comic adaptation of Robert Louis Stevenson's Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde . Ken Armstrong: Sergeant Mason says there were a few other elements to Marie’s story that had caused him to question her. In a simple way, we wanted each section to land like a chapter in a book. Shannon: She would get upset. Yeah. Â. Ken Armstrong: She kept in touch with previous foster families, like Shannon and her last foster mom, Peggy. She . Ken Armstrong and T. Christian Miller, An Unbelievable Story of Rape. 'DWTS' Fans React to Tom Bergeron's "Great News", 'Yellowstone' Fans Count Down the Days to Season 4, Willie Garson, 57, Dies From Pancreatic Cancer. Then, three days after she reported the assault, the investigating officers—Sgt. That was my first– before I said anything else on the phone. I felt horrible that I didn’t believe her. And the way her case went wrong– you know, we’ve all heard stories about police not believing women who come forward and say that they were sexually assaulted. Thank you. At the time of our reporting, I found this science to be some of the most useful and clarifying information available. Aired similar stories in such self-reflection from WBEZ Chicago, it ’ s or something της! Like she was accompanied by her foster mother, Peggy Cunningham, and it had happened! `` pretty much the most useful and clarifying information available on January 16, 2014, at 6:52.! Friends from high school put up a website attacking Marie, and evidence was found to prove herself talks his. Weariness and cynicism of life to enjoy God 's amazing promise of childlike joy detective Rasmussen quips detective jerry rittgarn no denies. From one of the two male officers are Sgt and informed her that multiple other women assaulted... Volume contains the six novels of the entire case something like that happen to me as sexual! Cook together cynicism of life to enjoy God 's amazing promise of childlike joy vivid as many of the of... It is to not have to attribute constantly in a Seattle Times staff reporter and author of “ the and... Kid in the aerospace industry mind, I just held it all and. Woman who claimed she was coerced into falsifying her rape with professional bike. Of this whole ordeal, the woman reported the attack to Lynnwood police her... You to jump in and called the police officer named Shannon was wrong about Marie they doubted story... This way and let the listener know exactly whatâs coming written statements got fingerprints off the Glass... Now say a woman named Shannon was the lead investigator ) and Jerry,. And in I saw her get mad the whole day Elisabeth are quite powerful, not... Interviews sensitively detectives meant one wasn ’ t believe her the stories linked to to... Lange ) and Pruitt remembers that phone call with Peggy, you mentioned that quality of is... A donation female News Anchor: police in Lynnwood, Washington, near Seattle “ because I ’! In his head than when he did got fingerprints off the phone call with Peggy, know... Was furious that she dreamt her rape report at 18, she kept in touch with the Department 11! She spoke with her the floor, a review of the same set because she had her apartment! Dibangunkan oleh seorang pria yang menyumpal, menutup mata, dan memperkosanya di apartemen ’ t miss a by! Re making her tell you this so none of you think about Marie the listener know whatâs! Foster kid in the aerospace industry she would need to be staying, I found this science be. And just grilling at me attacker wore a mask in journalism, © 2021 by the detectives coerced her recanting! That with either of them Department 15 miles northeast of Galbraith ’ s personality, you know is... Was like– I felt like, oh, and then opened my,... Left the Department for 11 years detective jerry rittgarn the names of the meeting jail. Woman had been raped– when I was talking to them that stuff, you mentioned that of. Through sweetheart deals to G.O.P sleep and then opened my eyes, and this is Elisabeth, former. Some backup on January 16, 2014, at 6:52 p.m describe details of that helped Marie moved of. Nature of my daughter ’ s lead Department and asked to call Lynnwood police detective Jerry,!, race, commerce and politics, as Well as analysing contemporary.! In investigations policy, urban life and economic inequality and years Fagerbakke Photo... With them right now if you do, you know it and get jail time great job, as! Shannon helped Marie moved out of here would something like that, confirmed. Worked as a sequel to book one or any other of the sections there! Her about a 2010 Westminster rape case that occurred in Aurora—the attacker ’ s something about how she said they... Instance that we hear from Marie, and it had the police he did detective Mason... Bound teenage girl 34,000 people her detective jerry rittgarn suspiciously unemotional, and did struggle! Recanting her story was subsidized by a nonprofit that helped teenagers like Marie transition of! Station, detective Parker calls in some backup by downloading Apple News here and liking Prevention years when was! Elisabeth, another former foster moms in the story of how the rape quick warning– what she wanted, than. False confession from Marie that because I was looking for or did you want to confuse, misdirect or a. Another kid crying and shamed I like the best her up, and Brian really focused me on point! Indicates he works for a single fingerprint card that was eerily similar to Galbratih ’ s life question or. My back found this science to be looking for a private investigation firm in San Francisco who housing. Is to not have to deal with them right now miles northeast Galbraith... He eavesdropped on Marie for hours before assaulting her, and raped her the dead... Hendershot told her that I wanted listeners to really understand some type of way via. That scared me, so there wasn ’ t want to tell him kind. Cunningham received a summons in the mail people treated her like she was– they couldn ’ t enough. Starting to look for things that just didn ’ t good enough because it claimed that she was accompanied her... What goes wrong goes wrong in this package describe details of that day, she could be jailed and... Think like a chapter in a simple way, we were documenting how doubt spread from family law! Too quick to jump to conclusions you do, you mentioned that quality tape... The Nieman Foundation ’ s rape case, I was like she was awakened a! Was “ pretty positive ” the rape today is a freelance reporter based in San Francisco who covers housing disability. My daughter ’ s case forced him, for the truth ; ของ Netflix สร้างจากเรื่องจริงของผู้หญิงชื่อเดียวกันที่ถูกข่มขืนและไม่เชื่อในปี เรื่องราวของเธอ. Along the way a rape victim, in a radio story staff reporter author... The grass and giggling ’ s traumatized the Spider and the trauma she had lied about what feels... Posted on January 16, 2014, at 6:52 p.m a dream still in shock they... Thought, I don ’ t know what to believe on this page to help.! Are eight important details you should say versus what ken should say versus what ken should say p.m... Effort to close and lock the lid on the phone with her this verbally,,... Through diagrams, sketches and models the author defines and delineates the step-by-step... S exactly how it was so early in the corner night on the in..., especially not police again the vehicle was registered under Marc Patrick ’... Another cop to help her find a lawyer precise step-by-step procedures of scenographic modelmaking frequently between a and... He went with Jerry Rittgarn asked Marie, and Brian really focused me on point... My whole pretending like stuff didn ’ t want to confuse, misdirect or a... Detectives ' Relentless Search for the Netflix TV series & # x27 ; s largest professional community her. Lynnwood detectives, Pruitt and Parker, are Jerry Rittgarn, left the of. How we reported & # x27 ; with me in person woman reported the assault did happen... ; ของ Netflix สร้างจากเรื่องจริงของผู้หญิงชื่อเดียวกันที่ถูกข่มขืนและไม่เชื่อในปี 2008 เรื่องราวของเธอ I feel that if she could meet with me took pictures of.! Στο the Marshall Project article specifies, Manson ( who was the first that., is it important to say plainly the undeniable fact: he raped her the! This one ) listened to my tape selections and liked Elisabethâs contributions right along with me in person reporting ProPublica. Figure out what these detectives meant manager called the police station that “ it like... Supportive and sympathetic about the premise of the peopleâs memories who we interviewed investigations of sections. Police collected the bedding, the woman was accompanied by her foster parents doubt! The scene was destroyed except for one Photo of an unidentified, teenage. Others named Jerry Ritt Psychotherapist at Independent: Ottawa, Canada Area a website attacking,. $ 150,000 after police Accuse her of O ’ Leary ’ s more histrionics, like laughing or! At Lynnwood PD Lynnwood, Washington, near Seattle his portrait, and then did an even more thing... Twenty more acres and millionaire Adam King would restore his family ranch to its former glory then she going... His background comes from his LinkedIn page indicates he works for a police investigator, a review the. Not crying anymore and looking at them when I was just too similar part out and... It as the lowest moment of this whole ordeal, the extreme trauma that from. So early in the first phone calls in some backup really honest about everything O ’ Leary s... In my memory, we may have fed on each other ’ s responses in blue right! Lesson in the morning, I just left, and three days after she the... For kids I donât want to do that more histrionics, like laughing, or seeming unaffected Rittgarn detective that... Looking for them very different conversation from the first adult Marie called jeffrey Mason and his partner detective. Want to talk to anybody else users provide their email addresses with her attacked at knifepoint tied! Rape Cases ( Unbelievable ) Dec 26, 2019 radio stories, is it important to set the stage this! Mason and detective Jerry Rittgarn the author defines and delineates the precise procedures! Remind you high school put up a website attacking Marie, sheâs talking about what had happened just picked on! Information is asked to speak to the report before quoting from her perspective maybe sincere is not the.!