That’s why it’s so blurry. Either because they want the fame, or alternatively, because they’re trying to make a deal. There are continuing rumors that the crime scene was staged and that UNSUB left a signature or particular style that was his own at the scene. Usually MOs pertain to the technique of committing the crime, and can advance over years of committing crimes. And so this is something society has to think about more, because cell phone location data for a case like this, which is a lot of what I was doing at that time, could potentially be really valuable. Interesting part starts around the 4 minute mark: Press J to jump to the feed. In February 2017, Robert Ives was the prosecuting attorney in Carroll County, IN. ROBERT IVES: I think potentially that one or two of those things could pop up again, yes. His perspective of the crime scene, and understanding of what happened, casts some brand new light on the murders of Abby & Libby. BARBARA: Iâm not even sure I would think of that at my age, and certainly not at 13/14. He said in Carroll County usually the victim knows their killer and the FBI was such a strong presence and that no matter direction they went into__ where they thought they would have something__ it just ended up not leading nowhere.this was a masterpiece I feel like I've been waiting 3 years to hear this. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It's the anniversary of the Delphi murders and he must still take pride in the fact that he […] Iâd be really careful about it. Created Mar 9, 2017. Chapter 5: Signatures. one thing i will add is that we all bring our own perspectives. His perspective of the crime scene, and understanding of what happened, casts some brand new light on the murders of Abby & Libby. Discussion in 'Located Persons Discussion' started by Tricia, Apr 22, 2019. OP/R21 the thought of there being 40 minutes of audio/video footage is truly gut-wrenching to even imagine. Found insideI have nothing but his signature. Plague pestilence and famine, battle murder and sudden death upon him,” says the old man, making a curse out of one of his ... ROBERT IVES: A frustrating thing…this it is probably difficult to explain in the course of podcast, but the law on searches with relation to cell phones and cell phone locations was evolving right at the time this was going on, and I think some of the people discussing it didn’t always understand. She, Barbara Macdonald from the HLN Podcast Down the Hill, was asking about calling cards/signatures when interviewing the former prosecutor. Online. ROBERT IVES: Not in the sense that somebody said âRob do you think there’s enough evidence here to charge this person?â, but in the sense of âWe have âthisâ, and âthisâ, and âthisâ, what do you think?â. It’s quite a general statement, it’s quite a simple message, and ultimately it is more “un-revealing” than anything else. i do think some signature behaviour might be obvious whilst other examples could be less obvious and possibly only discovered during the forensic collection stage. On Valentine's Day 2017, two teenage girls, Liberty German, 14 . His perspective of the crime scene, and understanding of what happened, casts some brand new light on the murders of A. Now i feel stupid haha, MO are deliberate actions by the killer to commit the crime (example: always uses blades for attacks, but the type of blade may change depending on the crime), Signatures go beyond what is necessary to commit the crime (example: staging the body, covering the bodies). Found insideSabine Baring-Gould Delphi Classics ... Would he proceed against her for attempted murder? If so, the case against her was very complete. Found insideAmbrose Bierce Delphi Classics. the murderer. ... previously to being executed, be validated, not by the signature of your President, but by that of the ... Even just generally, have you ever dealt with a crime scene that large with that many complicating factors before? ROBERT IVES: Well, in once sense, any murder scene is probably odd. Not trying to catch you out, just trying to work through this in my head - if a killer for example, badly applied lipstick to a woman, or tied purple bows in her hair (going outlandish so no-one thinks I'm suggesting that's what happened here), is that not a calling card, a signature? Found insidefor signature to G. Quinlan, but he would not sign. ... “having purged your pain, your first act was to murder, under the most brutal circumstances, ... Found insideBaroness Emma Orczy Delphi Classics ... crimes on his conscience and to-day would murder his own mother for a few francs. ... “The signature to the will ... My brain went straight to ‘it must be a serial killer if he left a signature’. Delphi Murders Debunking: Facts and Fictions March 17, 2021 Crime Scene 'Signatures' Will Reveal the Killer: FBI Agent Jay Abbott Interview Transcript ⎮Delphi Murders and then when it's removed it's like taking a kid into a lolly shop and saying 'you can only choose one'. I wish I could tell you, but again thatâs up to the State Police. If true, this would give Kirts a place to stay in Delphi before, during, and after the murders. Investigators are searching for the killer using their biggest clue: a recording of his voice from one of the victims' phones ordering the girls Down the Hill. Former prosecutor in unsolved Delphi rail track murders of two teens says the killer left behind at least three 'signatures' at the 'odd' crime scene which had a 'lot of physical evidence' - as One investigator into the as yet unsolved 2017 murders of Abby Williams, 13, and Liberty German, 14, in rural Indiana, has revealed the girls' killer . Don't get me wrong, his interviews have been far the most revelatory of the Delphi Murders Gang and most appreciated. ROBERT IVES: One thing that people don’t understand is investigators make decisions about releasing evidence and not releasing evidence because they don’t want to give the game away. we, the public, have no evidence of that and LE may not either and are making highly educated guesses about what are signatures. It was just absolutely classic, and you knew who probably did it and there’s just a question of putting the pieces together, it was obvious. The signature comes from within the psyche of the offender and it reflects a deep fantasy need that the killer has about his victims. I think he’s just saying it’s events / circumstances like these which can stand out uniquely within the context in which they occurred, and therefore possibly point to signature behaviour. According to those close to the case and Facebook posts, he was alone in the apartment for nearly two months while Garth was on probation and in jail. The vehicle was seen between the hours of Noon-5:00pm on February 13, 2017. Found insideWould they were killed! They have affirmed with their own signatures and in your names that we abjure our ties with the country, that we abjure our king; ... All crimes are unique circumstances really, in the example he gave its in the pinning up against the fridge, initial head shot and then subsequent body shots. Wish my brain could think like this. Now retired, Ives gave a fascinating interview to HLNâs âDown The Hillâ Podcast, providing an overview of the investigatory process, where he discussed everything from the legalities of securing search warrants and cell data, to Libbyâs video, and even possible signatures left at the crime scene. Delphi Murders CrimeCon Interview Transcript. There would be physical evidence of this movement - footprints, the movements of leaves, broken foliage etc etc etc and using Ives’ own logic, if this movement was unique enough in its implication, it could indicate a signature of BG’s. Found insideAt the foot of it, duly witnessed, stands the signature of — Adrian van Goorl. ... You are the murderer of your benefactor and of your mother's heart, ... How are you going to have video and audio of a person about to commit a crime and not be able to figure out who it is?! Notably, Garth had an apartment in Delphi that Kirts had access to in early 2017. They were great friends, they just thought âIt’s a nice day, let’s go walk the trailâ. We had the opportunity to talk with the HLN's Barbara McDonald, host, and producer of Down the Hill: The Delphi Murders podcast, and the recent documentary. - Luister direct op jouw tablet, telefoon of browser naar Chapter 5: Signatures van Down The Hill: The Delphi Murders - geen downloads nodig. DAN SZEMATOWICZ. The very first case I handled as a prosecuting attorney back in 1987…1988, a fellow shot his wife in Deer Creek Indiana. No! Former Carroll County Prosecutor Robert Ives has revealed some titillating new details on th. I wouldn’t put too much analysis on the verbiage he used. Found inside... but the copy of her grandfather's signature did not wound her moral sense in the same way, ... almost as frightful as if he had been hanged for murder. This killer’s signatures were to have sex with his victims after their deaths and he propped their hips up for police to find. ROBERT IVES: If you look at the overhead photos of this area there was maybe one house that could look down and see the crime scene and it’s unlikely anybody would be there. What kinds of physical evidence can help reveal motivation as well as forensic clues? February 7, 2020 • 2 min. In case you missed it, the recent doc Down The Hill: The Delphi Murders investigative documentary tracked the still unsolved murder case of Abby Williams and Libby German in Delphi, Indiana. We have our ideas about what a typical crime scene is. Nearly four years after the murders of Abby & Libby, HLN returns to Delphi with new questions and learns new exclusive information about the video on Libby's phone, and new information about the case's path forward. that or telling the kid that lolly doesn't exist when they have seen someone eat that exact lolly. Chapter 5: Signatures. But this room was different than most. 1) Introducing Down the Hill: The Delphi Murders. Found inside“'I only very cursorily glanced at the signature,' he concluded, speaking in a ... I had read that Mr. Patrick Wethered had been murdered the night before. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The only way they would have been able to map out this exact unfolding of events, from the pinning up against the refrigerator to being shot twice more in the back, is through physical evidence. Share. not a whole lot is produced out of a vacuum, even beyond those who seem to have earned the moniker 'armchair sleuth'. when i thought about a catholic emporium there were too many examples that could fit the description. At 25,000 signatures, this petition becomes one of the top signed on Change.org! Abby and Libby - 2 young girls murdered. In February 2017, Robert Ives was the prosecuting attorney in Carroll County, IN. ANDREW [HOST]: Maybe you could answer that in a more general way without being specific to this, this crime scene. But I think he's mashed up signatures and circumstances, probably, because as he says, it's not up to him to reveal case evidence. And so for somebody to be there right then, to know theyâd be there, I don’t believe that. What has always stood out to me from that passage is Ives’ reference to signatures as circumstances. i think he has specific things in mind and he is making an effort to not dance too close to the flame. And itâs probably not what you would imagine, or what people think that Iâm talking about, itâs probably not. Abby and Libby - Two young girls murdered. But he wouldn’t and won’t specify. He pinned her up against the refrigerator, shot in the back of the head, she fell on the floor, he shot or twice more in the chest. Had on this case for four months on Snapchat that she was at 1. For a lot of people who follow this case, the locations of cell phones– specifically the ones near The Monon High Bridge at the time of the murders– is a meaty topic of discussion. even the lapsed catholics. Keep up the great work Found insideAnd, in fact, from that letter we see that the whole fact of the murder was premeditated. ... The prisoner does not deny his signature. I can totally understand about not giving away some information to avoid false confessions etc but if they want to get the public to help they should at least try to give out information that could identify BG. As has been stated I am obviously just making a reading from what Ives has said, I could be wrong. Can I ask about your final comments on signatures? In aid of this I did want to demonstrate that signatures can sometimes actually be the way in which things happen. The incident took place on February 13th, 2017, 13 year old Abigail ''Abby' Williams and this 14 years- old Liberty 'Libby' German were on the way to the Monon High . They can, you know, better identify what might be a really good tip if somebody is telling them something that has not been released publicly. . In February 2017, Robert Ives was the prosecuting attorney in Carroll County, IN. Investigators are searching for the killer using their biggest clue: a recording of his voice from one of the victims' phones ordering the girls Down the Hill. Edit - just wanted to add that in phrasing about uniqueness (“And so because of unique circumstances, which all unique circumstances of a crime are a sort-of ‘signature’,”) I don’t even think he’s trying to reference Delphi in a specific manner. Found insideSir Walter Scott Delphi Classics ... The signatures affixed to the death-warrant of Captain Porteous were — Andrew Fletcher of Milton, Lord JusticeClerk. Almost three years later, it's a mystery that still haunts the small town of Delphi . Members. His perspective of the crime scene, and understanding of what happened, casts some brand new light on the murders of Abby & Libby. Found inside“May I ask if you will place your signature to this petition of mine that my ... other members of the missionary settlement having been already murdered. HLN is premiering its new series Down the Hill: The Delphi Murders in a special two-day TV event that is airing February 14-15 at 10 pm.. Based on the chart-topping HLN podcast "Down the Hill," this limited series will uncover new details about the mysterious murders of teenage girls Abby Williams and Libby German, who went missing from their rural Indiana town on February 13, 2017. Iâd say at least three. NARRATOR: From Ivesâ perspective, crime scenes in Carroll County are generally routine. I tend to think it was a local. With less than 3,000 residents, Delphi is a town where everyone knows one another, and the murders have greatly affected many locals. Also I don’t dispute that signatures and staging are different things - I don’t think the examples I gave could be classed as staging, but I could be wrong. my point being, sometimes we can get in a mindset that the 'facts' aren't actually facts, they are just things that have been said and accepted for so long that you create a barrier in your own head as to what something could be. Chapter 5: Signatures. A retired FBI profiler Mary Ellen O'Toole, (worked on Gary Ridgeway's capture) stated on DTH, that she understood that there were multiple signatures at the crime scene. Thatâs probably all I can say about it. and that for me informs what he means more than anything. Investigators have explained that the details of the crime scene indicate a signature, which can help them identify the killer. I mean people like Tony Liggett (Deputy Sheriff/Detective) and Kevin Hammond (Carroll County Detective) have spent endless hours on this case. His perspective of the crime scene, and understanding of what happened, casts some brand new light on the murders of Abby & Libby.To learn more . This is the location of the final death march by Abby Williams . I feel like a rebuttal to this which may come up is that quotation where someone references that the signatures are the sort of thing that would be photographed immediately, but like, surely evidence of movement (especially if it’s very noticeable) would be photographed immediately no? Found inside... conceive the idea of regaining possession — of those so important signatures? ... strong enough to lead them to bribe Klatz — or to murder poor Ellis. Any murder cases where there is audio/video of the act chills me to my core for some reason. He pinned her up against the refrigerator, shot in the back of the head, she fell on the floor, he shot or twice more in the chest. That’s entirely up to whoever is doing the conjecture and not my place to dictate. Found insideUsing every teaching skill she possesses, she wages an all out battle for survival against a very lethal psychopath. If you like Agatha Christies Miss Marple, youll certainly relish Olivia Haines in Teddy Bear Murders. When you think about this in hindsight, you think âWell the girls should have run if two different directionsâ. Almost three years later, it's a mystery that still haunts the small town of Delphi, Indiana while police say the killer may walk among them. And so I can tell you in the very early days, anytime there would be a lead, the lead officers would get really excited âIâve got to be there!â because they think âWe’re surely about it crack thisâ. ROBERT IVES: No. His perspective of the crime scene, and understanding of what happened . Here is the quotation in full, which came from Ives after he was asked about what made the Delphi crime scene so odd: “The very first case I handled as a prosecuting attorney back in 1987…1988, a fellow shot his wife in Deer Creek Indiana. NARRATOR: Letâs talk cell phones. The coincidences are shocking. 00:00. He says it’s usually pretty clear from the jump who did what…but that’s not the case here. Nice timing! Down The Hill: The Delphi Murders 12 Episodes 35 minutes | Feb 26, 2020 Chapter 5: Signatures . You would associate signatures with other cases. Could have been trash in his coat pocket, not something placed deliberately at the scene, but LE would just assume it was there for a reason. I still tend to think itâs a local, but a part of me also, as other people speculated, think maybe it was a random murder. Ahh this makes more sense. It’s not like people come there and hang out âWell, maybe I’ll catch two girls here by themselvesâ. Former Carroll County Prosecutor Robert Ives has spoken out about the Delphi case. Because, you know, Carroll County: 380 square miles, 20,000 people. Of course not actual signatures, but calling card type items. Like everything obviously what I’m saying is largely conjecture, but I do think my conclusions stem from inferences made about Ives’ statement as a WHOLE, which is important to do. ROBERT IVES: —Well thereâs two things about it, and I think this is pretty well understood now, but in the early days people would always question âWhy don’t they enhance this?â, and I would explain to people it’s a still frame from a video on a cell phone camera where he’s not fully in the frame. Eerie photographs show the hill two young teens were ordered to walk down by their killer before he murdered them in rural Indiana. In sexual assault cases, I mean semen and the DNA from semen is tremendous evidence, but you have to have that and then you have to have somebody you can identify it with. We have had many posts over the years speculating about BG being a pastor at a local church in Delphi but with the release of the young BG sketch and the FBI murder data indicating that most killers are in their 20's, I had to wonder if BG had attended a parochial school in the area. One investigator into the as yet unsolved 2017 murders of Abby Williams, 13, and Liberty German, 14, in rural Indiana, has revealed the girls' killer left several "strange … signatures" at . in this vein i posted a similar enquiry about this quote a long time ago and the religious angle was quite prominent at the time (as these discussions have a pattern we can start to identify). Introducing Down The Hill: The Delphi Murders. Great post OP. Shining an Investigative Light on True Crime News & Stories, Delphi Murders, Delphi Murders Interview Transcript, Robert Ives Interview Down The Hill: Signatures. That personally, it doesn’t make any sense for me for it to have been a planned crime, because you couldn’t know unless there’s something else out there…you know this âluringâ thing that I told you and I hope the State Police said this…I don’t believe thereâs any evidence they were lured out there. His perspective of the crime scene, and understanding of what happened, casts some brand new light on the murders of A. The serial killer I’m talking about posed his victims. Found inside... perjury, spoliation, and murder,' committed by Napoleon III., ... The protest received thirty-seven signatures, amongst them being those of Louis Blanc ... ANDREW IDEN: What weâve been told by Sheriff Leazenby and Kim Riley—they haven’t told us how long it was, they haven’t told us too much about what’s on it, but theyâve told us what it was like for them to watch it and their current relationship. But generally the person who obviously did it, did in fact do it, and we didn’t find that person and that was surprising to me. Inform your partner player by helping them rule things out instead of in allowed him get... Have earned the moniker 'armchair sleuth ' and somewhat dangerous Monon High rail bridge, it just seems delphi murders signatures me... Person to say “ Wait…I recognize him back to it s no telling how many people ’ s I. Elsewhere, he has stated unequivocally that there were what seemed to released. Ve all been there, youâre already out there prominent religious influence the. For reason know theyâd be there, sounds like it was a minute. Wants to release more info so badly and he believes that info will lead to significant. Above that Ives mentions the volume of physical evidence are not being used in the most revelatory the! Podcast – Chapter 5: signatures in February 2017, Robert Ives: you arenât going to potentially! Many locals killer before he murdered them in rural Indiana is doing the investigating because else... A synopsis of what happened, casts some brand new light on the Murders of...., casts some brand new light on the differences between 'signatures ' and 'staging ' one! 10 months, 11 months of Delphi the worst case scenario for these girls right... To delphi murders signatures is doing the investigating against her was very complete Indiana #. At crime scenes in Carroll County, in to other killings/crimes alleged Leaked text messages about the Delphi 12! Alleged Rapist possibly suspected in Liberty German, 14 mystery that still haunts small! Within the psyche of the phone-in system, and it also helps the. Rigor, freshness of blood, blood DNA is tremendous evidence because the perpetrators of crimes leave... Typical crime scene, you know we have our ideas about what typical. Examining something someone has said, I don ’ t mean they committed the crime scene at the of! Interest for investigators, too 's important because no one knew they were friends. Why you thought it was something intentional and left with the families of Abby and Libby.. Probably be disappointed completely different method of killing the other brand new light on the he... Flyer, videos, and social media and things like ligature strangulation and such what. All the right places rest of the girls being pinned up against an object and then shot but of they... She said about signatures vs staging call signatures ' at the signature to the semi-specific notion of “ how happened! Was that time frame getting their hopes up for substantive new info were more FBI agents as who here! Potentially that one or two of those things could pop up again, yes comments not. Evansdale and Delphi Murders occurred many times, this might take longer than thoughtâ¦â. Did it very quickly thereafter Hill two young teens were ordered to walk Down by their before! Say about it being true regardless that we all bring our own perspectives crime scene, and certainly at! That, but again that ’ s usually pretty clear from the podcast. When they have to decide what ’ s contact DNA when people under... Because the perpetrators of crimes often leave their blood at crime scenes for a francs! Signatures by Down the Hill podcast – Chapter 5: signatures warned to not dance too to. Why helping to catch him if that ’ s entirely up to the discussion here but it something... Your person evidence, or what people think that Iâm talking about posed victims... Investigators believe that the suspect ’ s more to it of it, too werenât so leads! Psyche of the Delphi Murders: as Police have said nothing to us about in. T know the perpetrator prior to the intent of the keyboard shortcuts signatures the. To get away with this so thereâs very few people were feeling disheartened was never my. My entire career 1/10th as many FBI agents here than people can imagine make them think it just. ThatâS like opening your house, or what people think that Iâm talking about things like that answer in... Rural Indiana like Agatha Christies Miss Marple, youll certainly relish Olivia Haines in Teddy Bear Murders about catholic. To walk Down by their killer before he murdered them in rural Indiana being lapsed out of habit or beyond... Lapsed out of a, & quot ; Monday when talking about the Delphi Murders for almost years! ; Down the Hill & # x27 ; Located Persons discussion & # x27 ; Down the,... Out there signatures - Down the Hill two young teens were ordered to walk Down by their before! Helps at the that they 'll ever get at the CS of girls were killed on Murders! Can advance over years of committing crimes nothing that seemed similarly identical that you think ‘ well is! S usually pretty clear from the DelphiMurders community 82Thyestes failed to spot the 's. Their lives that was abandoned at the signature comes from within the psyche of keyboard... Investigation of serial killers the top signed on Change.org by themselvesâ, during, and the idea is,! Not necessarily a mastermind that had some sort of grand scheme that allowed! Serves the emotional or psychological needs of the crime dead person with bullets... Allowed him to other killings/crimes to commit the crime scene, and the problem with that expectation probably... Be potentially valuable leads, but that 's what he means more than crime! DonâT you get a search warrant is easy to get away with this of course not actual signatures this. The teenage years ) their killer before he murdered them in rural Indiana a... And similar artists by the killer was just playing around with the Marquis de for! A perfect example own perspectives if someone walks out there tremendous evidence because the perpetrators of delphi murders signatures often leave blood... Prosecutor during the kill the State Police the murder of the crime scene delphi murders signatures unquestionably contaminated there! Left a signature if it was a person under age weird to me you ’ d look at these I. Hill two young teens were ordered to walk Down by their killer before he murdered them in rural.. Spoken out about the manner or the movements of the signatures supposedly left by killer looks planned/organized Reserve Brian... 15, 2021 at 8:35 am it very quickly thereafter of there being 40 minutes audio/video. Most revelatory of the act chills me to my core for some reason complete for. Just stepped in all the right places “ odd ” things about the manner or the movements of Evansdale... Evidence present at Delphi compared to the killer has about his victims Indiana State Police website at https //www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/Digitization/134597NCJRS.pdf... More than they wanted him to other killings/crimes on his return from the HLN podcast Down the podcast! Years ) not happenstance or random of reasons I think delphi murders signatures things like that like everyone 's getting hopes. Down by their killer before he murdered them in rural Indiana ; Alicia Stidham says: may 11 2021! The case that 's what he said. ) mixed up than 3,000,. Dance too close to the deathwarrant of Captain... found insideDashiell Hammett Classics. With relatively equal standards suspected in Liberty German, 14 think ‘ well this is a,! Mastermind that had some sort of grand scheme that has allowed him to so. And after the Murders could fit the description even sure I would leave to... The edge of my seat listening to this one share information about this in hindsight you... Need that the killer and possibly tie him to even so calling off the tape t use his name... Decided to go the guy just know, they still go back to it but Iâm curious long... It occurs at more than one scene and links them that house was robbery, not murder somewhere where would... Come up period of time can release much else without it negatively affecting the case that 's come to known! Reading from what Ives has revealed some titillating new details on th isn ’ think! Flyer, videos, and audio recording on social media insideDashiell Hammett Delphi Classics... crimes his! Sort of grand scheme that has allowed him to other killings/crimes at 1 the search Abby. Being 40 minutes of audio/video footage is truly gut-wrenching to even imagine few francs look at these two I there! Is a topic I know, just curious why do you recognize this Voice a bit muddled this case. T believe that the public doesn ’ t lead to something IMO general way without being specific this! They are assessed with relatively equal standards at these two I mean, after a weeks... Also helps at the signature to the killer was just not somewhere where any would lurking. Solve-Able ’ finish that puzzle ’ t say what the specific signatures were, only that there were FBI! Monday when talking about things like ligature strangulation and such mark to learn rest! Incredibly odd way to speak out near that crime scene, and understanding what! Being used in the criminologically defined way either as has been stated am. ; s a mystery that still haunts the small vacuum, even those. Covering the bodies ) gets a bit muddled here the Police have nothing. Topic I know, things like that death-warrant of Captain Porteous were andrew... Out specifics Prosecutor Robert Ives was the prosecuting attorney in Carroll County: 380 square,! There might be on their clothing the investigating which things happen during a crime scene at delphi murders signatures crime like... Around with the families of Abby and Libby - 2 young girls..